Neurodiversity approaches to autism, such as the “double empathy problem”, often make explicit comparisons between cross-cultural and cross-neurotype communication. This includes emphasising how power relations in both contexts contribute to framing minoritised groups as “communicatively impaired”. However, this metaphor often implicitly positions the neurodivergent person as someone who can communicate relatively fluently using spoken words. Neurodivergent people who use few words, have no access to symbolic language, and/or have profound intellectual disabilities are implicitly excluded by this metaphor. I suggest this is because this group of people complicate neurodiversity’s “culture” metaphor – it is difficult to describe their communication styles as “different”, and difficult to entirely dismiss the idea that they may have a communicative “impairment”. Drawing on ethnographic research into (mis)communications between staff and supported people in care services for autistic people with high support needs, this presentation/discussion session draws attention to this rhetorical failure, and asks: what are the limits of the “culture” metaphor of neurodiversity as it is currently used? Are these limits inevitable? Or, collectively, can we envision a better, more inclusive invocation of neurodivergent cultural differences – one that, perhaps, can sit alongside the concept of communicative impairment?